Monday, 29 September 2025

United States versus Europe

Dream On

I am not a great follower of golf; it takes too much time, doesn't provide much cardio exercise and it was too expensive when I spent a couple of years playing in the 1970s before the family arrived. However, I watched the current Ryder Cup event in the United States with a genuine excitement. The European golfers, drawn from Scandinavian countries, Britain, Ireland, Spain, and Austria, trounced the American team and their aggressively loud supporters, particularly on day one when President Trump was there to celebrate American greatness.

The 15 -13 result for the Europeans reflected the different attributes of the two teams. In the foursomes and four-ball matches, where team spirit counts, the European team established an 11.5 to 4.5 lead. In the individual matches, the Americans' thirst for hero status brought them back as they achieved an 8.5 to 3.5 victory.  Since the Europeans first became involved in the Ryder Cup in 1979, they have established a 13 to 9 victory over the Americans.

It made me reflect that my generation of baby boomers has grown up in a world where America was regarded as the top dog in everything - GDP, weapons, wealth, philanthropy, aeroplanes, consumer products, income levels, and new technology. And all of this was celebrated by a film industry that infiltrated and entertained the world and created the American dream. This year, the United States has lost much of this respect as it has cut international aid, withdrawn from international bodies, vetoed peacekeeping proposals at the United Nations, introduced arbitrary trade tariffs, threatened to take over some countries and failed to end conflicts in Gaza and Ukraine. The retreat of the USA into isolation and its withdrawal from international bodies has tarnished its reputation across the world. It should prompt a wider examination of whether Europe has been living on a misinformed assumption that the United States is any longer all-powerful. 

If we thought of Europe as federations of states, which they increasingly are, and draw comparisons with the United States, the perceived power and dominance of the USA would be far less convincing than it was in the latter half of the last century. Here are some useful comparisons.


The United States has a population of 347.275 million 
Europe has a population of 744,398 million, excluding Turkey

The United States had a GDP of $30,507 trillion in 2024
Europe had a GDP of $25,323tn trillion in 2024

As a matter of comparison, China had a GDP of $19,231 trillion and Russia $2076 trillion

If we look at the performance at the last Olympic Games in 2024, the medal table would read:

                               Gold.         Silver    Bronze

Europe                     119            121        151

United States             40             44           42

Europe, with twice the population, won three times as many medals

Or take Tennis, a sport that the United States dominated in the last century

Grand Slam winners since 2000

                            Men.    Women

Europe                  88          41
United States          6          38

And in the world's most popular sport, football, the United States is a mere minnow at the men's game, only notable for hosting the event three times, including next year.  Conversely, the women are the most successful team, winning the World Cup 4 times since its inception.

What does this tell us? Well, we have probably been duped into believing the United States always calls the shots and that we should do its bidding. When FDR Roosevelt was in his pomp, driving forward progress and seeking to establish an international order, this was a justifiable stance, particularly for Europe. Times have changed. Make Europe Great Again. (Mega)

Europe wins Ryder Cup again (13-9)

Thursday, 18 September 2025

Time for a dilatory Government to get radical

Visions of Britain

It is easy to forget that only just over a year ago, we were seeing the final dismemberment of the Conservative government that had ruled since 2010 and resulted in austerity, the collapse of the NHS, Brexit and extensive corruption and expulsions. It was a huge relief, and although the massive Labour majority of 170 seats overrepresented the popularity of the Labour Party, it was an accurate measure of the electorate's disdain for the Conservative government.

Over a year later, the Labour government is in deep shit. The Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, claimed we were entering phase 2 of his government just a week ago. It was meant to be a shift towards more active delivery. When Angela Raynor, the Deputy Prime Minister and Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, resigned following a failure to pay full stamp duty on a new flat, Keir Starmer, true to his principles of setting up an ethical advisor and acting upon any misdemeanour by members of the government, wasted no time in dismissing Angela Raynor or at least seeking a resignation letter from her. He has been consistently ruthless in dismissing or suspending Labour MPs who have transgressed since coming to power 14 months ago. The primary difference from the previous Conservative government is that any deviation from the line is identified and appropriate action is taken immediately. This was seldom the case with the last Conservative government, where 25 MPs were forced to resign, usually after the PM was forced to take action in the face of public outrage. 

It is a great pity that Keir Starmer has not been equally ruthless in implementing his promised change agenda. It requires a recognition that our constitution and governance structure are not fit for purpose, and an understanding that some radical policy changes are necessary. Unlike previous Labour Governments elected by landslides in 1945, 1966 and 1997, he arrived with no grand plan or vision, just a promise not to raise taxes and to provide a more ethical and diligent leadership than his predecessors. The cost of living continued to rise, his tax promises were broken by a sudden increase in National Insurance for employers, international aid was further reduced, and immigration levels remained high. He was not providing the big reforms that were needed and which Attlee, Wilson and Blair had been brave enough to introduce on the strength of their election victories. Stramer was tinkering; his first year wasn't convincing the electorate. The departure of Angela Raynor allowed him to reorganise his cabinet and junior ministers, but instead of releasing the energy and ideas of new MPs, he circled the wagons, shuffling ministers who were loyal to his vision of steadying the ship of state. This is not buying time; it is wasting time.

It is becoming increasingly urgent to invent an EV metaphor, to shift from neutral to forward if the government is to win back support from those who believed that things could only get better with a Labour Government. It is not so, as the latest opinion polls (averaging the results of the last seven polls in late August and early September) show that the Reform Party is 10% ahead of the Labour Party, and the Lib Dems and Greens are gaining support among left-of-centre voters. Change is no more than a mantra, and the shuffling of cabinet and junior ministerial appointments is indicative of a "coalition of the unwilling" when it comes to the radical change that is required to reverse the decline of the UK. The Reform Party has spent the summer inventing a hatful of populist memes that have propelled them forward. They are neither affordable nor realistic, but they trump the spiral of doom introduced by the Tory governments of the past 14 years and the stultifying, steady-the-ship mentality of Starmer's government.

Labour Party                        21%.
Conservative Party               17%    
Liberal Democrat Party       14%
Green Party                         10%
Referendum Party               31% 

I have never belonged to a political party, mainly because of the tribalism that prevents constructive debate about issues. I am clear that there needs to be some significant changes in the way the UK and Scotland function at a time when we are at best treading water. We need to re-enfranchise our communities, improve public services and infrastructure, accelerate progress, reduce inequalities and decouple from the fake fantasies and America First realities of Trump's rogue state. I would like to see the Starmer government address the wicked issues that the UK faces. In times of trouble, the answer is no longer let it be.

Constitution. It has been evident for many years that the UK's unwritten constitution is no longer fit for purpose. It has been kept because the two largest political parties have seen it as protecting their right to govern. Despite Blair's modest attempt to make the House of Lords less elite, it has become an enormous retirement home for ageing politicians and fellow travellers. Equally important is the need to embed local governance in the constitution and devolve powers away from the remote, nullifying and arrogant administrations of Westminster and Holyrood. Some form of proportional representation is needed for the House of Commons, and it is surely worth making voting mandatory through an identification card/app secured by biometric data.

Gaza. Recognising Palestine is merely a starting point. It is time to endorse the work of the United Nations independent International Commission of Inquiry that Israel has committed Genocide in Gaza.  Ideally, a UN peacekeeping force should have been mobilised, but the Security Council would have prevented this by virtue of the United States vetoing any such action. The result: 65,000 deaths.

Devolve power to councils. The concentration of powers and functions by central government, along with its numerous non-democratic bodies and regulatory bodies, has resulted in lengthy decision-making processes, poor procurement, corruption in the allocation of levelling up funding, and centralised tax raising, with core government funding for councils reduced by between 40% and 70% since 2010. Equally important, although seldom acknowledged, is the loss of ability to set local priorities, to harness the partnership between Councils and local businesses and the energy and commitment of local communities. Something evident in countries with a more federal governance structure and municipal muscle that is protected by local governance being embedded in the constitution.

Taxation Reform. This has been seen as too dangerous by successive governments, and Rachel Reeves has shown even less courage in this area by making promises to retain income tax, national insurance and VAT at existing levels. It is the cause of many of the travails of Starner's government. Integrating Income Tax and National Insurance would give a far more progressive taxation regime that would benefit younger workers.  and eliminate the NI advantages of being self-employed. VAT is a bureaucratic nightmare and needs simplification and extension to additional products and services that, on balance, benefit the wealthiest. Taxation on aircraft fuel would show a commitment to green policies, not dodgy green soundbites. And land taxation should be introduced and devolved to councils to fund the infrastructure required for additional housing and commercial developments. HMRC have been subjected to far too many fixes by a lottery of Chancellors, who, along with the Treasury, have muddled us along for too long 

National Identification Digital Card/Application: Why the UK lags behind the rest of Europe and the world on Digital Identity Cards has exacerbated our inability to tackle many other issues, such as work permits, benefits, demographic data, voter identification, immigration and the planning of public services. It was a no-brainer when David Blunkett tried to introduce it in  2009. The Lib Dems and Tories scrapped its development in 2010, but even they are now understanding its benefits. It would also seem to be the case that the Starmer government might be willing to bite the bullet. Get on with it.

Care and NHS funding. The Chancellor has announced an extra £30bn of funding for the NHS in the next three years, but only £4bn (a 2.6% increase per annum)has been set aside for Adult Community Care, and 80% of this has to be found by Council Tax increases. Baroness  Casey's Independent Commission is not due to complete until 2028, and the increases announced by the Chancellor provide no scope for eradicating the deficiencies in the service. The Treasury and the government are too obsessed with the NHS to address our underfunded Care sector

International Aid and the United Nations. Starmer has focused on restoring the UK's relationship with Europe and developing an unctuous relationship with Trump's America. But the further reduction of International Aid and the lethargic defence of Gaza at the United Nations have not rebuilt the soft power that was relinquished during the Johnson era. Hopefully, the changes at the Foreign Office may change this.

Green Issues. Despite the rhetoric of victory a year ago and the genuine efforts of Ed Miliband, there have been too many mistakes by the Treasury on Green issues. The shift to approving wind turbines and green energy has been positive, but the failure to tax fuel for air travel or to introduce the fuel escalator would have been far more sustainable tax increases than National Insurance. Then, to approve not one but two new runways at Heathrow and Gatwick, the first of which will not be operational for twelve years and cost over £21bn, runs contrary to previous inquiries that suggested only one was required and even then, subject to stringent environmental conditions. This contrasts with further delays to the Northern Rail Link between Liverpool and Hull. It would appear that the government is as wedded to investment in the South East as the last government. Our friends in the North are not happy.

Big Tech and the Water Industry. The involvement of Financial companies like BlackRock in advising the government, the overseas investors in UK industries such as Thames Water, Nuclear Power Stations and major Airports has extracted profits from consumer price increases. Big tech from American companies has been even more of a drain on consumer prices. And they are now making AI promises for a new age, but the only certainty is that they will be certain to make huge profits from the UK. It is an area where we would be better aligned with Europe on these developments. 

Immigration. The top issue, according to the opinion polls. Although there has been progress in processing asylum seekers and reducing the numbers in Hotels, there is a long way to go, and there will have to be hard choices taken to satisfy the manifest concerns of the resident population.  This requires a clear statement of the number of migrants, including asylum seekers, that can be granted permission to enter the UK. It should not be justified by salaries offered, but by the needs in the job market and by humanitarian reasons for asylum seekers. What is required is clarity and consistent, speedy administration of transparent policies, not military enforcement and demeaning the importance and value of immigration.

It's time for a little bit of progressive disruption.

 







Thursday, 4 September 2025

Favourite Places -2- Moor Nook

Moor Nook and River Ribble

Favourite places have to evoke strong images, friendships and the continuity of life's journey. My second choice after Langdale is Moor Nook, the large housing estate where I lived from the age of 4 to 18. It was built in the optimism of 1950s Britain, when things happened at a pace, and despite the old class system still hanging on, there were stirrings of an egalitarian revolution. Attlee's post-war government initiatives had been allowed to continue by Churchill's late-life apathy as PM. Thereafter, they continued more positively during Harold Macmillan's pragmatic tenure as prime minister at a time of increasing affluence for many families. His soubriquet of 'Supermac' certainly curried favour in Preston, which was festooned with new council estates, new schools, and the UK's first motorway, the Preston bypass, later to become the M6. Preston even elected two Tory MPs in 1959.

The essential ingredients of Moor Nook were well-constructed council houses planned in an attractive semi-circle of crescents, an award-winning new primary school, and a regular municipal bus service that ran like clockwork at seven and a half minute interludes to the town centre. It housed a double dose of baby boomers. There was an average of three children per house in my crescent, 57 of us in the first twenty houses. 

Dennis, who lived across the road, was my best friend.. We made every day an adventure and persuaded others to join in.  Less than a hundred yards away was a mixed woodland, Brockholes Wood, that covered the scarp slope down to the River Ribble. It provided a huge adventure playground for the children, featuring a natural sand pit, a vibrant birdlife and enough climbable trees to result in a steady stream of broken legs and arms to the local hospital. 

We had an equilateral triangle of grass just around the corner, which provided for regular impromptu football games for about ten to fifteen of us. Kicking downhill towards the woodland to the base of the triangle allowed lots of wide wing play, whilst uphill to the apex required a diamond formation. Even as eight- and nine-year-old mini Guardiolas, we understood the different formations to play in.  Cricket was played in the street with lampposts as wickets; it required leg spin from the gutter to left-handed batters like Dennis. There were few cars, and they were mainly three-wheeler Bond Minis, made in Preston, but generally found standing on bricks in gardens as the front wheels had a tendency to collapse. This meant that it was possible to extend a rope across the road and play tennis in summer, and make the rare cars, ice cream and grocery vans wait until points were finished before the rope was dropped. Although not designated as a play area, children ruled the street.

Few girls played these games, although they joined the boys for chasing games on roller skates and bike sorties. They mostly stuck to skipping and pushing doll prams. In 1960, Dennis and I organised a week of athletics during the Rome Olympic Games and attracted quite a few girls amongst the thirty or so participants. I recall that Janice Sutton, Eileen Sutcliffe and Bernadette, my neighbour's cousin, who came every day from her home over a mile away, were more than a match for most of the boys.

A row of shops was built about two years after we moved in, and they created a hub of activity. The cigarette machines took two shilling pieces and gave back 10 Players. Capstan or Senior Service and a halfpenny sellotaped on the packet, or you could get 3 Woodbines for 6d. This was a ready-made attraction for young smokers, almost as an effective recruitment for a lifetime of tobacco addiction, as the armed forces had been for our parents. Dennis smoked all three of our first packet of Woodbine we bought. This was after I started coughing and gave up after a couple of drags on my one and only cigarette. Dennis soon became a regular teenage smoker and a James Dean look-alike before he joined the Navy to get his daily ration of cigarettes.

Best of all was Brockholes Wood, where we could make dens, erect rope swings from the trees, play chasing games, observe the abundant birdlife, and watch older boys shoot air rifles and flee if they started firing at us. Films and TV cowboy series were the influencers for the baby boomers. It was only a ten-minute walk down to the River Ribble. We could fish for roach, chubb, and the occasional trout, paddle and swim in the summer and walk upstream to Ribchester during the winters when it froze over - the big freeze-up lasted  9 weeks in 1962.

The wood was breached in 1958 to construct Britain's first stretch of Motorway, the Preston by-pass, which eventually became the M6. Huge earthmoving machinery created a more sedate gradient up the original scarp slope. After the first layer of tarmac was laid in the summer of 1958, and when the men knocked off in the evening, we would race our bikes down the then two-lane motorway, reaching speeds in the high thirties according to the speedometer on my friend Nick's bike. My class from the nearby primary school were frog marched to the opening by Harold Macmillan in December 1959.

Life in the primary school was good; 550 children were crammed into a school designed for 400. There were 150 pupils in my year, split into 4 streamed classes. It was a happy atmosphere. In P5, my class had  23 girls and 13 boys, although by talking too much in class and not responding to being slippered by Mr Partington's size 8 Dunlop Tennis shoe, he banished me to the girls' side of the class, and as a further punishment, I had to line up with the girls. On some days, I would join them in their fast skipping games, and I asked Mr Partington if  I could enter the skipping race on school sports day.  When I won the girls' skipping race and the boys' running race, the girls were not happy, and he relented and allowed me to return to the boys' side of the class. Despite these travails, it did not seem to affect my enjoyment of school or support from the teachers. In the final year, I was made head boy and football captain, and managed to remain friendly with most of the girls.

The final year was made special by a teacher, Mr Duerden, who would take us on nature walks on sunny days and take us out to the playground to play cricket if we got restless. We learnt a lot about things that were not on the eleven-plus syllabus, and that had its downside. Only two boys and six girls passed the eleven-plus. A mere 5.3% of the roll for the year, whereas the average for the Education Authority was 13%. It also meant that I would have to go to the Grammar School, which was seen as a place for posh kids by my classmates who would be going to the local secondary modern school.

At the Grammar School, the first year was a challenge. I had always been friendly with everyone at the primary school, but I knew no one at the grammar school. There were cliques of boys who came from the more affluent suburbs and hung about together. Many of the boys had racing bikes - Dawes, Claud Butlers, Carltons, Holdsworth or Mercian with 5 Campagnolo gears and Mavic or Weinmann brakes. My old BSA bike was too small; an embarrassment in the bike shed. I spent many an hour drooling over what bike I would buy and what components it would have. At school, the boys from Fulwood and Broughton had cricket whites, bats, boxes and Dunlop sports shoes, whereas I just had a pair of Woolworth's plimsolls and a better bowling action. 

Dennis had been my best friend for the past six years.  He was a year and a half older than me; a charismatic character, who at the age of thirteen became a teddy boy with a leather jacket, James Dean quiff and a cigarette addiction. Although we still played football and hung about together, we were drifting apart. We were in his house on a wet February half-term holiday; his mother, Alice, had got a job, so there was no adult to moderate behaviour. We were playing Risk, a Waddington's game. His sister, Hazel, who was my age, wanted to play, but Dennis wouldn't let her; she was a girl. I took her side as it would be a better game with four of us; her younger brother was also playing. It erupted into a slanging match between Dennis and Hazel, and she sobbed her way to her room. I went up to calm her down and refused to play unless she was playing. I was accused of fancying her. She was a quiet, reserved girl who had never participated in street games or gone on our adventures in the woods or to the river. I hardly knew her, but my allegiance switched that day.

A couple of weeks later, Dennis and I were in the woods enjoying the danger of a new swing that arced out 30 feet above the sloping ground. Dennis fell and broke his arm. He returned from the hospital with his arm in plaster for 7 weeks. He was angry because he would lose his paper round, which financed his smoking and visits to the cinema. Hazel suggested to him that I could take his round for a while until he could ride his bike again. The paper round required a three-mile round trip to collect the newspapers. I was too young at 12 to get a paper round, but the newsagent was happy for me to cover for Dennis for a couple of months. I was keen to make a positive impression, and I got through the round quicker than Dennis; this was welcomed by the customers who responded by giving me sizeable tips when I collected their money on Friday evenings. 

Social problems were becoming apparent as I discovered on my paper round one evening, I happened upon a mixed-race girl who was a couple of years older than me. She was crying in the outhouse waiting for her mother to return from work. She told me that her mother would not let her have a key, so she had to wait in the outhouse after school every afternoon until her mother returned from work. She had never met her Nigerian father; he was a sailor, and she found it difficult to make friends at school. We talked for a long time, and I tried to reassure her that she would find things easier and be successful when she started work. A year later, she had left school, got a job and looked like a happy and attractive young woman. She would always wave as we went about our lives. It made me think about the unfair way people are excluded and made to feel unwanted because of their background.

Things had improved by the second and third year at the grammar school; being good at most sports gave you immunity from the stigma of living on Moor Nook. Although I kept up friendships with my former primary school friends, I became more interested in the girls attending the 3 girl's grammar schools who caught the bus in the morning. One of them lived around the corner and came out to watch a dozen or so of us play football on the triangle of grass in the evenings. We all played to attract her attention as if she were a football scout. At the end of the game, we would gather around and discuss the game, music and politics with her; it was the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis.  She selected me instead of Dennis to team up with and gifted me my first record- 'He's a Rebel' by the Crystals. I was chuffed, and Dennis was miffed. Teenage days had arrived.

It also became apparent that the estate was changing; the pride of living in a new house had worn off, better-off tenants were moving to new private housing developments, and new tenants were arriving, including households evicted from other schemes or from older terraced houses being demolished because they were below the tolerable standards.  The estate was acquiring a reputation as the roughest estate in the town. Teenage gangs were congregating, marriages were breaking up, immigrants were allocated houses, cars were becoming more common as  Bond Minis were cleared from front gardens and dispatched to the scrap yards. 

A family from Ghana had been allocated a house along the road from us. The man was a graduate mechanical engineer and worked at English Electric, later to become British Aerospace; his wife looked after their young child. She was tall and graceful, but there seemed to be a silent hostility to her from the neighbours. If we were playing football in the street, I would stop the game to let her pass with her baby in a pram. She thanked me, and I asked her where she came from. I was studying Africa at school, and I asked her which part of Ghana, and it opened up a conversation that led to a friendship. I would often leave the football game to chat with her. She was well educated and told me that I was the only person on the estate who spoke to her. She invited me to the house to meet her husband, and I would occasionally babysit for them if they had to go out. This raised questions from some of the neighbours, who asked my mother why I was always chatting to the black woman. 

By the time I was 16, I had entered the sixth form, something I had not even contemplated a couple of years earlier. In Moor Nook, many of my former primary school classmates had left school at 15, and Dennis was sailing around the world with the Navy. Hazel had blossomed and become a hairdresser and was dating professional footballers who called to collect her in their Lotus Cortinas. We were given more freedom at school, and the teachers were more personal. They encouraged me to apply for university, something that had never crossed my mind. I had started going to the pub on Friday evenings with my classmates from the Grammar School and friends from Moor Nook; it was a rite of passage. We began to appreciate the huge variety of local beers available at the local pubs; in summer, we would do a pub crawl of the nearby country pubs on our bikes.

We arranged a twelve-day hill walking holiday in the Lake District during the summer holidays. Four of us from Moor Nook, plus two other friends, gathered at my house to plan the route; my mother was always pleased to have friends coming round. We booked the Youth Hostels to reach the main fells - Scafell Pike, Helvellyn, the Langdale Pikes and Skiddaw.  We traversed the fells, visited pubs and attempted to make friends with groups of girls. I changed our itinerary after we met a group of girls from Leeds.  

An older friend had bought an Austin Cambridge, and we would spend weekends and holidays at a rented barn on Lake Windermere that his father and several neighbours shared. They had a sailing dinghy that provided us with the opportunity to take risks in quirky winds and usually managed to capsize. On other days, we would walk the high fells on the better days and visit the Lakeland pubs in the evening. I wanted to take up rock climbing, but there were no takers while we were still at school. 

My final year at school and living in Moor Nook was a bit like my final year at primary school. I had progressed every year, made lots of friends, my grades were good, and I liked the teachers., Things had worked out, although the loss of my grandma on the day before my Maths A-level exam really fazed me. The head teacher offered me the chance to be House Captain, Depute Head Boy and encouraged me to apply for an Oxford scholarship. It would mean not leaving school until 19. Moor Nook boys liked to move on, so I accepted one of my university offers from Sheffield University to read Geography.

I had worked during the summer before leaving for Sheffield, and it felt like one of those tipping points in life as I prepared to leave home and say farewell to friends and neighbours. My father hired a car on a Friday, and together with my grandad, we drove through Manchester and across the Snake Pass to Sheffield. I had a single old suitcase with 5 shirts, a pair of Levis, a navy blue crew neck jumper, a pair of shoes and a pair of Adidas trainers. My father had also bought me a car radio that he had converted to be used as a battery radio. My digs were in an old Edwardian semi occupied by two elderly spinsters; the digs had no redeeming features, but there was a shortage of Halls of Residence and being at the end of the alphabet never helped. And that was it. 

My grandad was in tears; we had always been close, and my grandma had died just 3 months earlier. He would be alone. My brother would have his own bedroom, and the family acquired a dog in my place. Moor Nook was just a place I visited for part of the holidays and on the occasional weekend when friends scattered to Manchester, Leeds, London, Glasgow, and Oxford would return to Preston to meet up. It had been a great place to grow up, with lots of friends and to acquire values that would last a lifetime.