Monday, 8 May 2017

Carn Mor & Bidean a' Chabair, Glen Dessarry

Carn Mor from east ridge
Friday 5 May 2017

Ascent:    1920 metres
Distance:  22 kilometres
Time:        10 hours 34 minutes

Carn Mor                829m    2hrs 26mins
Bidean a' Chabair   867m    5hrs 41mins


We parked at Strathan and walked in to the A' Chuil bothy in Glendessary. It was being refurbished but we were going to camp in any case and we walked another 400 metres before finding a suitable site. As always it was impossible to find a flat patch of ground but the dry soft grass provided a comfortable mattress. It was another sun-basked morning and we managed to get away before 8am, climbing straight up from the tents to the 5 kilometre long east ridge leading to Carn Mor. The first 550 metres of ascent was a stiff climb, I took the left ridge and John and Keith went up the right ridge and once on the broad summit ridge the vistas opened up. We were treated to that rare event in this part of the world, a sunny day with the cool easterly wind making it pleasant for walking and ensuring excellent visibility. We took a longish break at the summit, which we reached just after 10am. Three retired seasoned walkers with over 6000 munros climbed between us, we deserved a rest, so many outings in the past had been during long days when time was the essence and weather conditions not conducive to stopping.

The OS map does not provide the best of detail in these remote parts but we found a feasible route down the north east ridge and then by following a burn that dropped steeply to the glen below. We had lost almost all our height and had another longish break at the burn whilst we topped up our water bottles and viewed the grassy ramps leading to the summit ridge of Bidean a' Chabair. Keith started at his usual steady pace and made the summit 10 minutes before John and I. We passed an elderly couple on their descent near the summit, they were staying at Strathan in a camper van and had watched us arrive the night before. They were envious that we were about to complete our second Corbett of the day and described themselves as 'one a day walkers'. Bidean a' Chabair was about the limit of their range and they had cycled up Glendessary for the first 5 kilometres.

The final 100 metres of ascent was a delightful walk through a group of small lochans with a steepish scramble to the splendid rocky summit. With Knoydart to the north and Rum and Skye to the north west, we were spoilt for views and this was further extended when an eagle appeared over the twin summit of Sgurr na h-Aide. We had hoped to be here by 2pm but had made it with some time to spare so we celebrated with a good half hour stop. John and Keith were getting close to finishing their round of Corbetts, or third round in the case of Keith. They had a palpable sense of being 'nearly there' as this was possibly the most remote Corbett.

Our descent was by a series of grassy ramps back to where we had started the climb and then we had a 2 kilometre walk along a glorious sinuous valley that bisects the two corbetts. There was a steep final climb before dropping to the edge of the conifer plantation and the trail back to Strathan. We entered the forest through a broken gate and followed a boggy path alongside a burn for a kilometre until we reached the river. The dry weather meant an easy crossing of the river to reach the track on the other side that continues through the forest for a couple of kilometres until it emerges near the A Chuil bothy. We met a young German walker heading towards Inverie, he was ecstatic about the conditions and the fact that we had left our tents whilst we went for the walk without any fear of any theft. He loved the values of collective honesty and the freedom of the Scottish wild places. We persuaded him to take a diversion up Sgurr na Ciche in the morning as he said that he was ahead of schedule and had time to spare and looked to have the energy to tackle the best of the Knoydart munros.

We packed the tents and walked back the final 5 kilometres to Strathan along the good track. It was a perfect evening although still chilly in the easterly breeze. We met several walkers heading into Knoydart for the weekend and reached the cars before 7pm. The drive out along Loch Arkaig was, as usual, both frustrating and slow but the drive home was in the best of May conditions. The views of the grey corries and then Glencoe were quite sublime but hunger drove us on so there were no stops for photos.

Loch Arkaig in late evening
Setting off for A' Chuil bothy in the evening
Loch Morar and Rum from Carn Mor
Carn Mor ridge
Descending from Carn Mor
Approaching Bidean a' Chabair summit
Loch Nevis from Bidean a' Chabair
Sgurr na Ciche and Garbh Chioch Mor from Bidean
Job done on Bidean summit


Me descending Bidean, Sgurr na Ciche behind
Strathan on the walk out

Sunday, 7 May 2017

Sgurr an Utha

Sgurr an Utha from Drum na Brein-choille

Thursday 4 May 2017

Ascent:      747 metres
Distance:   8 kilometres
Time:         3 hours 1 minute

Sgurr an Utha       797m    1hr 50mins

At last, a dry spell of weather with high pressure over Scandinavia, giving Scotland blue skies, low humidity and a chilling easterly wind. These are the best of walking conditions, so John and I arranged to travel to Morar to climb two of the remotest Corbetts after each of us had climbed separate remaining Corbetts as an aperitif. I dropped John below Braigh nan Uamhachan, next to Gulvain, and drove on for an extra 6 miles to Sgurr na Utha. I had passed the steam train travelling to Mallaig from Fort William just before dropping John, so when I parked at the top of the incline at Cross beyond Glenfinnan, I walked down to the railway line to take some photos of the locomotive as it steamed up the incline. I was soon joined by a photography boffin from Bolton who was on a 3-month post-retirement tour of Scotland. 

The locomotive had stopped and then must have lost steam at Glenfinnan, so we had to wait about 40 minutes before the distinctive sound of the Stanier Black Five locomotive echoed up the glen. It was almost noon before I grabbed my rucksack for the short excursion up Sgurr an Utha. The track that begins just east of the bridge at Cross rises steeply and after about a kilometre forks to the right and climbs up to 500 metres. From here it is a pleasant climb upwards at first and then along a knolly ridge before the final climb to Sgurr nan Utha. There were splendid vistas back to Ben Nevis across Loch Eil and, as I alighted on the final ridge, the Glenfinnan Munros and Streap were impressive peaks. Knoydart, Skye and Rum were all visible, and the nearby Loch Beoraid shone an azure blue.

I had made reasonable time on the ascent and gave myself 15 minutes to enjoy the views and take a few nibbles. I had arranged to meet John at 4pm, so I began the descent just after 2pm and took a direct line back to the track. It was a surprisingly easy descent over grass with only a few outcrops to avoid. The track took me down quickly, and I was back at the car park where a couple of Highland Council road workers had coned off my car in the new car park. They were about to seed the land alongside, but more ominous was a tar machine standing by to presumably put the final layer of tar where my car was standing.

The steam train rattled past on its return from Mallaig, almost freewheeling down the incline. I drove down to the junction with the A861 to collect John, but I was early, so I sat in the sun for half an hour. We then drove to Neptune's Staircase on the Caledonian Canal at Banavie, where we met Keith Adams. He was nearing completion of his third round of Corbetts to add to almost five rounds of Munros and four rounds of tops. The remote Loch Arkaig duo of Corbetts, Carn More and Bidean a' Chabhair, were his main remaining obstacle, and we had agreed to join him.

We had an early tea at the Bar/restaurant by the canal before setting off on the long single-track road to Loch Arkaig. It was a doubly difficult journey as the Scottish motorbike trails were taking place by Loch Treig, and dozens of bikers were heading towards us at speed on the single-track road. Then we had the arduous 13 miles of the single-track roller coaster up the length of Arkaig. We packed our rucksacks and at about 8pm began the 5-kilometre walk to the A'Chuil bothy so we would be ready for an early start in the morning. The bothy was closed because a party of volunteers were restoring it, so it was as well that we had taken tents. It was a warm night and too early in the season for the midges to have emerged.

Ben Nevis over Loch Eil
Sgurr Thuilm and Streap from the summit
Route down
Loch Beoraid from the summit
Knoydart and Skye from the summit
Black Five approaching Cross summit
Ben Nevis

Friday, 5 May 2017

Tory cabinet

As we watch the Tories surge into the election with a 15% lead, I am flabbergasted by the incompetence of Mrs May's cabinet. Yes, Iain Duncan-Smith may have gone after creating a 21st-century Dickensian landscape through his lamentable management of Universal Credit, but many other placements are unsuitable for the office. Priti Patel, Liz Truss, Sir Michael Fallon, and Chris Grayling appear completely out of their depth in the posts they currently occupy. Boris Johnson, Liam Fox and Andrea Leadsom are only there because of their Brexit fakery. Having Michael Gove in the cabinet is akin to keeping the genie in the bottle; there is no end of damage he would cause if allowed out of the tent. Perhaps it is what Mrs May intended when she tried to pick a cabinet from across the many cabals of Tory MPs.

The Tories usually had a few frontbenchers who could be seen to be working well with their briefs, even David Cameron had a place for Ken Clarke and 'two brains', David Willetts. In Theresa May's government, Greg Clarke, Phillip Hammond and the excellent David Gauke seem to grasp their briefs but are targets for the backstabbers. On the back benches, there are notable stalwarts like Sara Wollaston, Heidi Allen, and Stephen McPartland, who seem to be thinking for the wider good, but they are out of tune with the majority of their colleagues.

So what should a Labour Cabinet look like, certainly not the motley crew that constitutes Jeremy Corbyn's current shadow cabinet? They lack the gravitas to occupy ministerial positions just as Jeremy Corbyn lacks any leadership ability. There are exceptions, and it is encouraging that some of the next generation are being given opportunities. His most trusted lieutenants, Diane Abbott, Emily Thornberry and Richard Burgon have a grating presence that alienates many voters. A government should have a cabinet that embraces all the talents of the Labour Party, but there is no chance of Jeremy Corbyn embracing the broad church of MPs. Given the opportunity, some MPs have the experience and capability that could make a difference, but they come from either end of the broad church. I would also make space in the cabinet for Caroline Lucas, the Green MP,  to ensure that climate change is addressed and integrity is enforced.

Hilary Benn
Andy Burnham
Yvette Cooper
Mary Creagh
Stella Creasy
Jon Cruddas
Thangam Debbonaire
Harriet Harman
Meg Hillier
Dan Jarvis
Peter Kyle
David Lammy
Clive Lewis
Ed Milliband
John McDonnell
Pat McFadden
Ian Murray
Lisa Nandi
Rachel Reeves
Keir Starmer
Wes Streeting
Rosie Winterton

There are quite a few of less well-known MPs here, but compared to the present Tory cabinet of incompetent and unrepentant Brexiteers, it would give the country a chance to rectify many of the existing policies that are having damaging outcomes for the environment, social justice, and the economy. They may just be able to find a way to eliminate the devastation of Brexit by either revisiting the vote once the details are fully specified or ensuring a trading agreement. Anything would be preferable to the spurious bucket list of soundbites that the electorate was offered in the referendum.












Tuesday, 2 May 2017

Hart Fell and Broad Law

Broad Law summit
Monday, 1 May 2017

Ascent:       1401 metres
Distance:    22 kilometres
Time:          6 hours 13 minutes

Hart Fell                850m   1hr 32mins
Talla Reservoir      350m   3hrs  47mins
Broad Law             880m   5hrs 18mins

After a visit to Portrack House, Dumfries, for a day of Cosmic speculation, we stayed at Moffat so that I could climb the two nearby corbetts: Hart Fell and Broad Law. I had intended to climb Hart Fell from Ericstane on the river Annan in the morning before being collected and driven round to the Megget Stone to climb Broad Law in the afternoon. Aileen dropped me at the bridge before Newton and I began the 5 kilometre long ascent up Well's Rigg and Arthur's Seat. The going was easy on gentler slopes and dry ground and I arrived 45 minutes ahead of schedule despite the strong easterly wind. As I reached the summit I received a message to saying that my lift would not be back until 1:30pm as she had gone to visit Drumlanrig Castle, one of the Duke of Buccleuch's many palaces, castles and houses.

I would be down by noon so I decided to extend the walk by finding a route over the intervening hills to Din Law and then past the Gameshome Loch and Games Home Burn to the Talla reservoir. It was rough back country that had no sign of useage. As I dropped into the Games Home glen, the winds abated and the warm Mayday sunshine beckoned. My main concern was that my message to be picked up at the Megget Stone at 3:30pm may not have been received and I had no phone reception. Aileen might have to make an unnecessary 20 mile trip back to Moffat and then another 25 miles to the Megget Stone. Still it was a bank holiday and time was on our side so I hoped for the best.

The walk down the burn was enjoyable although there was no path and the ground was rough grassland. I was guided by the looming presence of Carlavin hill that overlooked the Games Home bothy. The bothy looked to be in pristine condition, the second in four days. From here there was an old track down to the end of the Talla reservoir, I passed a young couple having their lunch and we struck up a conversation. They seemed surprised that I had walked over from Hart Fell and then even more surprised that I was going to climb Broad Law. I must be looking my age.

The decision to tramp over the hills had been a good one but I had lost 500 metres in the descent to Talla Linnfoots. They would have to be regained and then some more to reach Broad Law, which is the highest hill in the Borders. I reached the road at Talla Linnfoots and decided to walk up the steep single track road to the bridge that is a kilometre short of the Megget Stone. Anxious to save time I climbed steeply up the southern flank of Fans Law. I did not find the path until I reached the ridge above Cairn Law.

From here it is a deceptively long haul out to the summit of Broad Law. The dry conditions made it a relatively easy walk on a steady gradient. I followed the fence posts, which made a swing to the left for the final kilometre. By this time I had confirmation that my lift had arrived. The summit hosted a tracking station for Edinburgh airport along with a trig point. They relieved the tedium of the endless grassy slopes but the weather was perfect and the walk back to the Megget Stone was a lazy ramble. A pot of tea and a slice of coffee and walnut cake at Broughton was a suitable reward for a good day's walk.

Hart Fell ascent from Ericstane

Looking east from Hart Fell

Hart Fell summit plateau
On the descent to Talla reservoir, Carlavin hill on right
Gameshope Bothy
Looking back over Fans Law to Lochcraig Head and White Coomb
Broad Law fence to the summit
Edinburgh airport tracking station

Sunday, 30 April 2017

Portrack, Garden of Cosmic Speculation


Snake Mound and Lakes

We had been sent tickets by our daughter for the annual one-day opening of Portrack Gardens of Cosmic Speculation just north of Dumfries. The house and gardens had been developed by the American architect and definer of postmodernism, Charles Jencks, and his first wife Maggie Keswick. It is a place where science and the arts come together in landscapes that are "a radical hybrid activity". They are according to Jencks "non-linear sciences that touch all aspects of life and a foil to the modernistic sciences that are fractured and simplistic".

Aileen and I did not really know what to expect, this was part of Scotland's Gardens open day and the event was raising funds for Maggie's cancer care centres. They were founded in memory of Maggie Keswick and have been operating successfully in twenty or so locations mainly in the UK.

An email sent the day before advised us to avoid arriving at opening time as there would be traffic jams to get into the parking area. We took the advice but everyone else must have delayed their arrival as well and we joined the mile-long traffic jam to reach the estate entrance. It took 40 minutes to travel the last 2 miles and already the early arrivals were blocked in as they tried to exit on the single-track road. We met Aileen's friend. Adrienne, and her husband, David, on arrival and began the journey into the magical landscapes. It was a cool but bright day as we began to explore the sculptures and random paraphernalia that sit alongside the Dumfries to Kilmarnock railway line.

We were not disappointed, the place was heaving and the gardens were buzzing with excited adults and quizzical children or that may have been the other way round. The paths provided the chance to absorb the strange juxtaposition of objects. Jencks had had great fun with bulldozers, chainsaws and acetylene torches. The sparkling white Portrack house was the only traditional object on the grounds. The adjacent property was the perfect country retreat in the fertile Nith valley.

We ran into several old acquaintances from the world of community development and tourism who seemed equally intrigued by the experience. We wondered if the paltry three portaloos serving 5000 guests were part of the cosmic speculation or whether Jencks was just having a laugh. After 4 hours of walking and absorbing the gardens, or should that be a radical hybrid activity, we left bemused but happy. I had booked accommodation in Moffat so that I could indulge in some hill walking on the next day.

A celebration of Scottish philosophers, philanthropists and poets

Bridge to nowhere or diving board to the River Nith

Scottish Bloodline

Tits or Bum?

Spiral Mound

Adjacent property and rural idyll

Community development royalty seeking cosmic solutions

Portrack House

Walled garden

Saturday, 29 April 2017

Streap, Glen Finnan

On summit of Streap, Loch Shiel behind

Friday, 28 April 2017

Ascent:                1407 metres
Distance:             18 kilometres
Time:                   8 hours 35mins

Stob Coir nan Cearc   887m   4hrs 35mins
Streap                         909m    5hrs 14mins 

After a night spent in 'Chase the Wild Goose' bunkhouse in Banavie, we were glad to be off for an early start. Streap is an inaccessible Corbett at the head of Glenfinnan. I have crossed its northern ridge on a couple of occasions on traverses from Gulvain to Sgurr Thuilm but never had the time to sample its steep summit. We started from the foot of Gleann Dubh Ligne on the trail through the conifer plantations. It was cool but bright and rain felt imminent. I had left my map in the car and made a bad mistake as we left the forest by a gate. A muddy path ascended to the southern ridge of Beinn an Tuim and we had climbed the first 100 metres before John pointed out that were heading too far south and it would add considerably to the route.

We decided to traverse round Being an Tuim, which seemed logical but ended with us spending a couple of hours negotiating our way through wet greasy rock bands, crossing numerous burns and scrambling up precarious outcrops. My feet had blistered in boots that I seldom wear and my waterproof trousers were slowing me down. I had put them on when the rain started but we just had a series of gentle showers.

We watched the morning steam train heading towards Glenfinnan, the inimitable sound of a Black Five hammering up the gradient from Loch Eil. When we reached the bealach before the sharp ascent of Stob Coire nan Cearc, we took the opportunity to eat an early lunch and reflect on the mistakes I had made on the ascent. From here on it was a fairly straightforward route over several tops before the final 70 metres of climbing up the arete to Streap. We arrived shortly after the cloud had enveloped the summit but during a drinks break we were treated to the curtain opening and reasonable views of the surrounding hills including the nearby Munro, Sgurr Thuilm, and Comhlaidh Streap, the twin peak of Streap which looks even more impressive.

We began the easy walk over the ridge to Comhlaidh Streap so that we could complete the horseshoe and we were treated to the best weather of the day. The rain was a gentle patter all day but not enough to wet us in the breeze. There is a long steep descent from this summit to the glen below, a 600-metre drop over relatively easy but steep grass and heathers. It was well drained so a quicker part of the day. Then the walkout down the corrie and into Gleann Dubh Ligne. We found a footbridge and passed the bothy, which had undergone extensive repairs after a fire and was looking splendid. We were back down just after 5pm. It had taken a couple of hours longer than expected but that was mainly down to my tendency to always head upwards instead of seeking the gentler but longer routes.


Ascent of Beinn an Tuim

Streap from Stob Coire nan Cearc

Stob Coire nan Cearc from Streap

Streap from Streap Comhlaidh
Gulvain from Streap Comhlaidh

North from Streap Comhlaidh

Looking back up Coire nan Cearc

Beinn Iaruinn and Carn Dearg, Glen Roy

Thursday 27 April 2017

Beinn Iaruinn        802m      1hr 31mins

Ascent:      701 metres
Distance:   7 kilometres
Total Time:         2 hours 45 minutes


Glen Roy has 4 corbetts, three of which go by the name of Carn Dearg. We had climbed the two at the head of the glen last year, and today was to be Beinn Iaruinn and the Carn Dearg at either side of the Glen. It is a slow drive up the glen, admiring the Parallel Roads that provide physical contours as relics from the ice age. We parked at the foot of Beinn Iaruinn and followed a steep path that leaves by the bridge. The weather looked threatening, and there was a stiff breeze to remind us that it is still April despite the plaintive cry of the cuckoos. Hills like this have few endearing features; it became a familiar plod up the dead bracken and brown heathers with rasping breath and wet feet to add to the dubious pleasure.

Arriving on the ridge gave us cloud-obscured views across Loch Lochy to Meall na Teanga and Ben Tee. The hillside of wind turbines beyond Invergarry was illuminated by shafts of sunlight, an accolade for green credentials. Cloud restricted the views in all other directions. At least I was able to put on my new waterproof jacket that I had bought over a year ago and never had to use in 30 outings in 2016. The walk over the ridge to the summit was over easy stony ground, and progress was easy despite the wind. We stopped briefly at the cairn before returning by much the same route. There was no wildlife and no incidents, but as a means of regaining hill fitness, it was a worthwhile outing. We drove a couple of miles further up the road and had a bite to eat before beginning the climb up Carn Dearg.

Start of Being Iaruinn ascent

Ben Tee and the wind farm to the northwest

Looking west to Meall na Teanga in the cloud

Summit of Being Iaruinn

Carn Dearg             834m     1hr 40mins

Ascent:      671 metres
Distance:   7 kilometres
Time:         2 hours 58 minutes


It is always a challenge to start the second walk of the day, and this was no exception. I had hoped that the brief interlude of sunshine might be a sign of a better afternoon. We crossed the wooden bridge, the bothy was closed, and a dead lamb was a reminder of the harsh environment in this remote glen. There is a 400-metre ascent up grass and heathers to make the higher slopes, which then curve around over a rain-soaked plateau and then up two more inclines to make the summit. The rains began in earnest and tested my jacket better than any testing tank as the wind hurled raindrops of all dimensions and even gave us some sleat on the summit. 

The views diminished, and our survival instincts told us to get down rather than hang about, so we made a return by the same route, not stopping until the primroses broke my step at the 300-metre contour; they never seem to go higher than this. The rain stopped as we finished, so we could change and begin the retreat from the glen and head to Corpach, where we hoped to find a bunkhouse for the night.


The bridge across to Carn Dearg

Glen Roy

John at summit

Summit view on Carn Dearg

Time to retreat